Taking Restorative Justice Seriously
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5935/25.38.2022.11118Keywords:
Restorative Justice, Criminal Legal System, Crimes, VictimAbstract
Those seeking to reduce mass incarceration have increasingly pointed to restorative justice—an approach that typically brings those affected by a criminal offense together in an attempt to address the harm caused by the offense rather than to mete out punishment. This Article is an attempt to think seriously about incorporating restorative justice throughout the criminal legal system. For restorative justice proponents, expanding these practices raises a host of questions: Does the opportunity to alleviate mass incarceration justify collaboration with a deeply flawed criminal legal system? Will the threat of criminal prosecution destroy the voluntariness and sincerity that is essential for a successful restorative process? Can restorative justice be successfully used in cases where the victim cannot participate or there is no identifiable victim, as in drug offenses? Will the process be coopted by bureaucratic impulses? Restorative justice skeptics may ask whether applying a restorative approach to the most serious crimes will jeopardize the deterrent value of criminal law and lead to outcomes that are vastly disproportionate. Those both inside and outside the movement will ask whether restorative justice can be implemented in a way that protects defendants’ procedural rights and is racially equitable. I explore the choices and trade-offs that would be involved in expanding restorative justice to significantly reduce incarceration. I argue that restorative justice can be expanded without significant adverse impacts on due process, racial equity, and proportionality. At the same time, vastly expanding restorative justice entails compromising some key features of restorative justice. I suggest that the disadvantages of expansion are significant, but are outweighed by the moral imperative to experiment with alternatives to mass incarceration.
References
David R. Karp & Olivia Frank, Anxiously Awaiting the Future of Restorative Justice in the United States, 11 VICTIMS & OFFENDERS 50, 51–52 (citing studies); see Heather Strang & Lawrence Sherman, Repairing the Harm: Victims and Restorative Justice 2003 UTAH L. REV. 15, 19–20 (2003).
JAMES FORMAN, LOCKING UP OUR OWN 220–21, 230–31 (2017).
NAZGOL GHANDNOOSH, THE SENTENCING PROJECT, THE NEXT STEP: ENDING EXCESSIVE PUNISHMENT FOR VIOLENT CRIMES 8 (2019).
William Wood, Why Restorative Justice Will Not Reduce Incarceration, 55 BRIT. J. CRIMINOLOGY 883, 887 (2015).
ALLAN MACRAE & HOWARD ZEHR, THE LITTLE BOOK OF FAMILY GROUP CONFERENCES 14 (2004).
HEA THER STRANG, RESTORA TIVE JUSTICE CONFERENCING (RJC) USING FACE-TO- FACE MEETINGS OF OFFENDERS AND VICTIMS: EFFECTS ON OFFENDER RECIDIVISM AND VICTIM SATISFACTION 2627 (2013)
Amy J. Cohen, Moral Restorative Justice: A Political Genealogy of Activism and Neoliberalism in the United States, 104 MINN. L. REV. 889, 893 (2019)
Thalia González, The Legalization of Restorative Justice: A Fifty-State Empirical Analysis, 2019 UTAH L. REV. 1027 (2019).
Michelle Alexander, Reckoning with Violence, N.Y. TIMES (Mar. 3, 2019), https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/03/opinion/violence-criminal-justice.html.
Carolyn Boyes-Watson, Looking at the Past of Restorative Justice: Normative Reflections on its Future, in ROUTLEDGE INTERNA TIONAL HANDBOOK OF RESTORA TIVE JUSTICE 7, 7–14 (Theo Gavrielides ed., 2019)
HOW ARD ZEHR, THE LITTLE BOOK OF RESTORA TIVE JUSTICE 25 (2002).
RUTH MORRIS, STORIES OF TRANSFORMA TIVE JUSTICE 254 (2000).
Kay Harris, Transformative Justice: The Transformation of Restorative Justice, in HANDBOOK OF RESTORATIVE JUSTICE: A GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE 555, 563–65 (Dennis Sullivan & Larry Tifft eds., 2006).
Heather Strang & John Braithwaite, Introduction, in RESTORATIVE JUSTICE AND CIVIL SOCIETY 1,1 (Heather Strang & John Braithwaite ed., 2001)
ROSS LONDON, CRIME, PUNISHMENT, AND RESTORA TIVE JUSTICE 23–24 (2011).
Margarita Zernova & Martin Wright, Alternative Visions of Restorative Justice, in HANDBOOK OF RESTORATIVE JUSTICE 91, 91–92 (Gerry Johnstone & Daniel W. Van Ness ed., 2007)
Daniel W . V an Ness, Creating Restorative Systems, in RESTORA TIVE JUSTICE AND THE LAW 130, 131–35 (Lode Walgrave, ed., 2002)
GERRY JOHNSTONE, RESTORA TIVE JUSTICE: IDEAS, VALUES, DEBA TES 2 (2002)
HOWARD ZEHR, CHANGING LENSES: RESTORATIVE JUSTICE FOR OUR TIMES 19–50 (2015)
DANIELLE SERED, UNTIL WE RECKON: VIOLENCE, MASS INCARCERATION, AND THE ROAD TO REPAIR 17–49, 91–128 (2019)
DA VID O’MAHONEY & JONATHAN DOAK, REIMAGINING RESTORATIVE JUSTICE 44 (2017)
Linda G. Mills, The Justice of Recovery: How the State Can Heal the Violence of Crime, 57 HASTINGS L.J. 457, 462–63 (2006).
Jim Parsons & Tiffany Bergin, The Impact of Criminal
Justice Involvement on Victims’ Mental Health, 23 J. TRAUMATIC STRESS 182, 184 (2010); Uli Orth, Secondary Victimization of Crime Victims by Criminal Proceedings, 15 SOC. JUST. RSCH. 313, 314 (2002)
Patricia A. Resick, Psychological Effects of Victimization: Implications for the Criminal Justice System, 33 CRIME & DELINQ. 468, 475 (1987).
T. Van Camp & J.A. Wemmers, Victim Satisfaction with Restorative Justice: More than Simply Procedural Justice, 19 INT’L REV. VICTIMOLOGY 117, 126–27 (2013)
ALL. FOR SAFETY & JUST., CRIME SURVIVORS SPEAK 14, 15, 16, 20 (2016).
Caroline Angel et al., Short Term Effects of Restorative Justice Conferences on Post-Traumatic Stress Symptoms Among Robbery and Burglary Victims: A Randomized Control Trial, 10 J. EXPERIMENTAL CRIMINOLOGY 291, 292 (2014)
Barton Poulson, A Third Voice: A Review of Empirical Research on Psychological Outcomes of Restorative Justice, 2003 UTAH L. REV. 167, 172, 179, 181, 188 (2003)
MARTHA MINOW, WHEN SHOULD LAW FORGIVE? 153–54 (2019).
Stephen P. Garvey, Restorative Justice, Punishment, and Atonement, 1 UTAH L. REV. 303, 306–07 (2003).
Jim Dignan, Towards a Systemic Model of Restorative Justice: Reflections on the Concept, its Context, and the Need for Clear Constraints, in RESTORATIVE JUSTICE AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE: COMPETING OR RECONCILABLE PARADIGMS? 135, 135–36 (Andrew von Hirsch et al. eds., 2003).
R. A. Duff, Alternatives to Punishment or Alternative Punishments?, in RETRIBUTIVISM AND ITS CRITICS 43 (Wesley Cragg, ed. 1992); see also R.A. Duff, Restorative Punishment and Punitive Restoration, in RESTORATIVE JUSTICE AND THE LAW 82, 96–97 (Lode Walgrave, ed., 2002).
JOHN BRAITHW AITE, RESTORA TIVE JUSTICE AND RESPONSIVE REGULA TION 74–78 (2002).
TOM TYLER, WHY PEOPLE OBEY THE LAW (1990); TOM TYLER & YUEN J. HUO, TRUST IN THE LAW: ENCOURAGING PUBLIC COOPERATION WITH THE POLICE AND COURTS (2002).
Cullen et al., Prisons Do Not Reduce Recidivism: The High Cost of Ignoring Science, 91 PRISON J. 48, 51 (2011)
BUREAU OF JUSTICE STATISTICS, 2018 UPDATE ON PRISONER RECIDIVISM: A 9-YEAR FOLLOW-UP PERIOD (2005-2014) 1 (2018).
Lawrence Sherman et al., Are Restorative Justice Conferences Effective in Reducing Repeat Offending? 31 J. QUANTITATIVE CRIMINOLOGY 1, 1 (2014)
KA Y PRANIS, THE LITTLE BOOK OF CIRCLE PROCESSES (2015).
MACRAE & ZEHR, supra note 8, at 13–17 (describing 1989 legislation providing for family group conferences for all serious juvenile non-homicide crimes in New Zealand); Carolyn Hoyle, The Case for Restorative Justice, in DEBATING RESTORATIVE JUSTICE 1, 29 (Chris Cunneen & Carolyn Hoyle eds., 2010)
Mary Louise Frampton, Finding Common Ground in Restorative Justice: Transforming our Juvenile Justice Systems, 22 U.C. DA VIS J. JUV. L. & POL’Y 101, 104–105 (2018).
U.S. DISTRICT COURT, DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS, RISE PROGRAM ST A TEMENT (2017); Telephone interview with Maria D’Addieco, RISE Probation Officer, (D. Mass) (Jan. 30, 2019).
Sara Sun Beale, Still Tough on Crime: Prospects for Restorative Justice in the United States, 1 UTAH L. REV. 413, 419 (2003)
O’MAHONEY & DOAK, supra note 21, at 123–26, 148. See also generally Diane Crocker, Implementing Restorative Justice Projects in Prison, 28 CRIM. JUST. POL’Y REV. 45 (2015).
Mark S. Umbreit, Betty Vos, Robert B. Coates & Elizabeth Lightfoot, Restorative Justice in the Twenty-First Century: A Social Movement Full of Opportunities and Pitfalls, 89 MARQ. L. REV. 251, 265 (2005).
Nils Christie, Conflicts as Property, 17 BRIT. J. CRIM. 1 (1977).
Theo Gavrielides, Restorative Justice -The Perplexing Concept: Conceptual Fault- Lines and Power Battles within the Restorative Justice Movement, 8 CRIMINOLOGY & CRIM. JUST. 165, 167–68 (2008).
M. Eve Hanan, Decriminalizing Violence: A Critique of Restorative Justice and Proposal for Diversionary Mediation 46 NEW MEX. L. REV. 123 (2016)
William Wood & Masahiro Suzuki, Four Challenges Facing Restorative Justice, 11 VICTIMS & OFFENDERS 149 (2016)
Paul McCold, Toward a Mid-Range Theory of Restorative Criminal Justice: A Reply to the Maximalist Model, 3 CONTEMP. JUST. REV. 357 (2000); Zernova & Wright, supra note 17, at 92.
Richard Delgado, Goodbye to Hammurabi: Analyzing the Atavistic Appeal of Restorative Justice, 52 STAN. L. REV. 751 (2000).
Mara Schiff, Can Restorative Justice Disrupt the ‘School-to-Prison Pipeline?’, 21 CONTEMP. JUST. REV. 121, 123–28 (2018)
Thalia Gonzalez, Keeping Kids in Schools: Restorative Justice, Punitive Discipline, and the School to Prison Pipeline, 41 J.L. & EDUC. 281, 298–321 (2012).
CAROL BOYES-WATSON, PEACEMAKING CIRCLES AND URBAN YOUTH: BRINGING JUSTICE HOME (2008)
Donna Coker & Ahjané Macquoid, Alternative U.S. Responses to Intimate Partner Violence, in COMPARATIVE PERSPECTIVES ON GENDER VIOLENCE: LESSONS FROM EFFORTS WORLDWIDE 169 (Rashmi Goel & Leigh Goodmark eds., 2015)
Mimi Kim, Moving Beyond Critique: Creative Interventions and Reconstructions of Community Accountability, 37 SOC. JUST.14 (2011)
Esteban Lance Kelly, Philly Stands Up: Inside the Politics and Poetics of Transformative Justice and Community Accountability in Sexual Assault Situations, 37 SOC. JUST. 44 (2011).
Jennifer Gerarda Brown, The Use of Mediation to Resolve Criminal Cases: A Procedural Critique, 43 EMORY L. J. 1247, 1288–90 (1994)
Tina S. Ikpa, Balancing Restorative Justice Principles and Due Process Rights in Order to Reform the Criminal Justice System, 24 WASH. U. J. L. & POL’Y 301, 311–17 (2007).
Gerry Johnstone, Voluntariness, Coercion, and Restorative Justice: Questioning the Orthodoxy, 3(2) INT’L J. RESTORA TIVE JUST. 157 (2020)
Adam Crawford, Institutionalizing Restorative Justice in a Cold, Punitive Climate, in INSTITUTIONALIZING RESTORA TIVE JUSTICE 120, 130 (Ivo Aertson, Tom Daems, & Luc Robert eds., 2006)
Daniel C. Richman, Professional Identity: Comment on Simon, 40 AM. CRIM. L. REV. 1609, 1609–10 (2003).
hristopher D. Lee, They All Laughed at Christopher Columbus When He Said the World was Round: The Not-So-Radical and Reasonable Need for a Restorative Justice Model Statute, 30 ST. LOUIS U. PUB. L. REV. 523, 546 (2011).
Bruce A Green & Lara Bazelon, Restorative Justice from a Prosecutor’ s Perspective, 88 FORDHAM L. REV. 2287, 2289 (2020).
MARYLAND JUDICIARY, STATISTICAL ABSTRACT 32, 40 (2017)
Susan M. Olsen & Albert W. Dzur, Reconstructing Professional Roles in Restorative Justice Programs, 2003 UTAH L. REV. 57, 59 (2003)
Adam Crawford, The State, Community, and Restorative Justice: Heresy, Nostalgia, and Butterfly Collecting, in RESTORATIVE JUSTICE AND THE LAW 101, 121 (Lode Walgrave ed., 2002).
Carolyn Boyes-Watson, What Are the Implications of the Growing State Involvement in Restorative Justice, in CRITICAL ISSUES IN RESTORA TIVE JUSTICE 216 (Howard Zehr & Barb Toews eds., 2004)
Theo Gavrielides, Repositioning Restorative Justice in Europe, 11 VICTIMS & OFFENDERS 71, 77–81 (2016).
Ann Skelton & Cheryl Frank, How Does Restorative Justice Address Human Rights and Due Process Issues?, in CRITICAL ISSUES IN RESTORATIVE JUSTICE 204, 208 (Howard Zehr & Barb Toews eds., 2004).
GABRIELLE MAXWELL & ALLISON MORRIS, FAMILY, VICTIM, AND CULTURE: YOUTH JUSTICE IN NEW ZEALAND xviii, 127–28, 191 (1993).
Loreen Walker, Restorative Justice without Offender Participation: A Pilot Program for Victims, RESTORA TIVE PRACS. F. 2 (Feb. 10, 2004)
Sven Zebel, Wendy Schreurs & Elze G. Ufkes, Crime Seriousness and Participation in Restorative Justice: The Role of Time Elapsed Since the Offense, 41 LAW & HUM. BEHA V. 385 (2017).
Janine Geske, Achieving the Goals of Criminal Justice: A Role for Restorative Justice, 30 QUINNIPIAC L. REV. 527, 540 (2012)
Gerry Johnstone, Restorative Justice for Victims: Inherent Limits?, 5 RESTORATIVE JUST. 382 (2017).
Carolyn Hoyle, Securing Restorative Justice for the ‘Non-participating Victim in NEW VISIONS OF CRIME VICTIMS, 97, 107–10
PRISON POLICY INITIA TIVE, MASS INCARCERA TION: THE WHOLE PIE (2020)
IAIN BRENNAN & GERRY JOHNSTONE, BUILDING BRIDGES: PRISONERS, CRIME, AND RESTORATIVE JUSTICE 16–17 (2018)
Alana Saulnier & Diane Sivasubramaniam, Effects of Victim Presence and Coercion in Restorative Justice: An Experimental Paradigm, 39 LAW AND HUM. BEHAV. 378, 384 (2015).
ILLINOIS COURT ADR SOURCEBOOK, https://www.aboutrsi.org/court-adr-across-illinois/programs/restorative-justice-community-court-cook-county-north-lawndale (last visited Apr. 6, 2021)
COMMUNITIES FOR RESTORATIVE JUSTICE, https://www.c4rj.org/ (last visited Apr. 6, 2021).
FANIA DA VIS, THE LITTLE BOOK OF RACE AND RESTORA TIVE JUSTICE 69–70 (2019).
Diane Crocker, The Effects of Regulated Discretion on Police Referrals to Restorative Justice, 36 DALHOUSIE L.J. 393, 397–99 (2013).
Nancy Rodriguez, Restorative Justice, Communities, and Delinquency: Whom Do We Reintegrate? 4 CRIMINOLOGY & PUB. POL’Y 103, 109, 119 (2005).
Kathleen Daly, Restorative Justice in Diverse and Unequal Societies, 17 LAW IN CONTEXT 167, 181 (2000).
Ellie Piggott & William Wood, Does Restorative Justice Reduce Recidivism?, in ROUTLEDGE INTERNA TIONAL HANDBOOK OF RESTORA TIVE JUSTICE, 359, 359–76 (Theo Gavrielides ed., 2019)
Lawrence W. Sherman, Heather Strang, Evan Mayo-Wilson, Daniel J. Woods & Barak Ariel, Are Restorative Justice Conferences Effective in Reducing Repeat Offending? Findings From a Campbell Systematic Review, 31 J. QUANTITATIVE CRIMINOLOGY 1, 10–11 (2015).
LAWRENCE SHERMAN & HEATHER STRANG, RESTORATIVE JUSTICE: THE EVIDENCE 9 (2007).
Hadar Dancig-Rosenberg & Tali Gal, Restorative Criminal Justice, 34 CARDOZO L. REV. 2313, 2327 (2013); John Braithwaite, Restorative Justice: Assessing Optimistic and Pessimistic Accounts, 25 CRIME & JUST. 1, 60 (1999).
DEP’T OF JUST., SPECIAL REPORT: VICTIMIZATIONS NOT REPORTED TO THE POLICE, 2006-2010 4–8 (2012), https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/vnrp0610.pdf.
Allegra M. McLeod, Envisioning Abolition Democracy, 132 HARV. L. REV. 1613, 1628–1630 (2019).
E.g., Paul H. Robinson, The Virtues of Restorative Processes, the Vices of “Restorative Justice”, 1 UTAH L. REV. 375, 381 (2003).
Paul H. Robinson & John M. Darley, The Utility of Desert, 91 NW. U. L. REV. 453, 478 (1997)
Michael Cavadino & Jim Dignan, Reparation, Retribution, and Rights, 4 INT’L REV. VICTIMOLOGY 233 (1997).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Authors of papers published in this journal declare to acklowledge and agree with the following rules:
1. The submitting of any colaboration implies on free and complete assignment of the copyrights to the journal, which is not obligated to return the originals of submitted colaborations.
2. Published papers represent the expression of the author’s point of view, not repressenting an oficial position of Juris Poiesis jornal, or Univesidade Estacio de Sas’s.
